El Cajon Police Department Cases

Case Status:OPEN


Douglas E. Pengilley


Douglas E. Pengilley DOB 12/31/73 WHITE MALE, 6’, 200 LBS, BLACK HAIR, BROWN EYES Pengilley was last seen in the winter of 1992 leaving El Cajon in a white 1992 VW Rabbit.

Gustavo Juan Cabrera

Gustavo Cabrera

Gustavo Juan Cabrera  AKA  “Gus” DOB 02/19/1950 5’10” 170, BLACK HAIR, BROWN EYES LAST SEEN OCTOBER OF 1977 IN EL CAJON Cabrera was diagnosed with PTSD after returning from Vietnam. He disappeared from his home in El Cajon in 1977 more »

James Ronald Peters


James Ronald Peters DOB 04-20-69 19 YEARS OLD WHEN HE DISAPPEARED LAST SEEN 09/03/88 WHITE MALE, 5’10”, 140, BLOND HAIR, HAZEL EYES Jamie was last seen on 09/03/1988 in El Cajon. His VW bug was later found burned and stripped more »

Pamela Sue Dyson


Name: Pamela Sue Dyson (AKA) Pamela Sue Marsh Dob: 11/22/1958 Age: 49 Race: White Height: 5’11” Weight: 155 Hair: Brown/Gray Eyes: Hazel Scars/marks/tattoos: Glass right eye Dyson was last seen in February of 2003. Dyson last resided at 771 El more »

Penny Lee Earlywine

Penelope Keehner-Earlywine 001

A.K.A. Penny Lee Earlywine, A.K.A. Keehner. Age: 44 years old at the time of her disappearance Height: 5’4″ Weight: 120 Hair: Blonde Eyes: Blue Earlywine, (AKA Keehner) was 44 years old at the time of her disappearance. She was last more »

Christopher George Schafer


Name: Christopher George Schafer Dob: 07/21/1969 Age: 38 Sex: Male Race: White Height: 6’3” Weight: 230 Hair: Black Eyes: Brown Schafer was last seen on 08/06/1997 driving his grandmother’s vehicle. The vehicle was located on 09/12/1997 on the Sycuan Indian more »

Jack Eugene Waller


Name: Jack Eugene Waller Dob: 03/15/1954 Age: 54 Race: White Height: 6’00” Weight: 230 Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue Narrative Waller was last seen on September 27, 2007 by his brother at his residence in El Cajon. Waller suffers from schizophrenia more »